This post is pretty different from those that precede it. This wasn’t inspired by a certain passage of scripture, but from constant questions that have been flooding my mind. I don’t mean for this to discourage or to cause doubt. I just need to get this all sorted out in my own mind. I am merely questioning, not doubting. I know and firmly believe that there are answers to these questions, I just don’t understand it yet. I guess this is my inner theological side coming out.
I know the question is vague and not very original, but lately I’ve been wondering why. Why does life and eternity need to be the way that it is? Why is my eternal bliss justification for another man’s eternal torment? Why would you begin something that would result in not only perfection and love, but imperfection and separation? Why is Heaven worth Hell?
For a while I’d forced myself to be content with the answer that it was simply all worth it, and that it was just beyond my understanding. That eternal damnation for some was just collateral damage so the rest of creation could glorify God. This could still be the right answer, but it just hasn’t been cutting it for me recently.
Five days ago I randomly remembered a short story I read in Mr. Fasciglione’s AP Lit class my junior year of High School. It was the story of a Utopia, a perfect society almost beyond our understanding, Omelas. The only catch to this perfection was the torture, torment, and agony of one child. Without this wretched child perfection couldn’t exist. This week I finally realized that Omelas was Heaven.
We could never appreciate or understand light without the darkness. Without wet, we wouldn’t have dry. Batman cannot exist without the Joker. We would never thirst if we were unaware of drinking. You could never be bored if you were never entertained. The warmth of a blanket would mean nothing without the bitter chill of a December wind. The necessity of an opposite has always intrigued me. You can’t have or understand something without having something else to compare or contrast it to. You can’t have Heaven without Hell.
This revelation brought me back to basically the same answer I had before, just with more understanding. Our love and communion with God is so important to Him and to the display of His glory that we needed to be created. In order for our love and affection toward Him to be pure and genuine, it needed to result from free will. In order for there to be that choice, there must be an opposite to choose. Since God is all things, and nothing existed before or outside of Him, this choice must come from within Him. Sin is merely a perversion to the attributes of God. Righteous anger, hate, jealousy, love, and all other things were twisted and their meanings distorted with selfishness. This creation of sin occurred only so we could fully understand the perfection that is God. We must then choose between this original righteousness and this distorted unrighteousness, and in doing so either Love in the way that it was all created for or reject this purity that God requires.
We are the gray in the equation, with the choice between the pure light of God and the darkness of the adversary (I’m not even going to get into the issue I’m having in understanding how God existed before Satan. I think the fact that it is all a perversion of what always was is the only way that this idea could work…). Unlike the basic principles that all have an opposite, we are caught in the middle. We are damp with the option of drying out or soaking ourselves. We are a thermostat sitting at 68 degrees, either to be cranked up to an inferno or dropped down to absolute zero. We are given the choice to be either the dusk or the dawn. It is this duality of man that makes our Love a genuine love.
So I have officially ranted for 686 words and haven’t gotten too far. I’m sure this wasn’t beneficial to anyone else reading this (all two of you, if I’m lucky), but it has helped me a ton. I still have a lot of things running through my mind, I just can’t bring myself to type it all out now. My mind is fried and I haven’t even scratched the surface.
I hate getting caught up in things like this. God, give me the wisdom and understanding I need in order to know you more, but keep me from the futility of my own mind. Let my relationship with you be deep yet simple…